Bennedict Mathurin played 25 minutes off the bench on Tuesday, accounting for 19 points (7-of-16 FGs, 3-of-3 FTs) and two 3-pointers.
Since Aaron Nesmith returned to the starting lineup on March 1, Mathurin’s fantasy value has taken a significant hit. He’s averaged 15.0 points, 1.7 rebounds, 1.3 assists, 0.7 blocks, and 1.0 3-pointers in three games while shooting 38.2% from the field. That isn’t even top-200 per-game value in 8- or 9-cat formats. Mathurin scored well on Tuesday but offered nothing beyond the points and 3-pointers. While he isn’t a must-drop in deep leagues, standard league managers should look for alternatives, especially with Indiana only playing two more games in Week 19. Nesmith struggled in Dallas, finishing with six points, one rebound, two assists, and one 3-pointer in 22 minutes.